5 Insightful Analyst Inquiries From Etsy’s Fourth Quarter Earnings Discussion

Etsy’s Q4 Performance Surpasses Expectations

Etsy delivered fourth-quarter results that pleased investors, as the company’s profitability outpaced analyst forecasts even though buyer activity remained subdued. Leadership credited these results to strategic changes within the core marketplace, including a renewed focus on customer satisfaction and increased investment in targeted marketing—especially on platforms like TikTok. CEO Kruti Goyal highlighted that upgrades to Etsy’s mobile app and more personalized marketing are starting to boost user engagement and retention, stating, “Our app is now our most tailored and interactive platform.”

Key Takeaways from Etsy’s Q4 2025 Results

• Revenue: $881.6 million, narrowly missing analyst projections of $884.4 million (3.5% year-over-year growth, in line with expectations)
• Adjusted EPS: $1.34, slightly below the anticipated $1.36 (a 1.8% shortfall)
• Adjusted EBITDA: $222.5 million, exceeding the forecast of $213.4 million (25.2% margin, a 4.3% beat)
• Operating Margin: 14.7%, down from 18.2% in the prior year’s fourth quarter
• Active Buyers: 93.54 million, a decrease of 1.92 million compared to last year
• Market Cap: $5.14 billion

While management’s prepared remarks are insightful, analyst Q&A sessions often reveal deeper insights and address challenging topics. Here are the questions that stood out to us this quarter:

Top 5 Analyst Questions from Etsy’s Q4 Earnings Call

• Trevor Young (Barclays): Asked about the sustainability of recent gains in reactivating buyers. CFO Lanny Baker noted that ongoing investments in product, app, and marketing have led to steady, lasting improvements, with social media channels playing a key role.
• Michael Morton (MoffettNathanson): Queried the influence of AI-powered commerce on Etsy’s advertising segment. CEO Kruti Goyal replied that while agentic channels are still emerging, they show strong potential for high-value discovery, and Etsy Ads continues to have room for internal optimization.
• Rakesh Patel (Raymond James): Sought details on strategies to attract younger shoppers and win back inactive customers. Baker pointed to increased TikTok spending and app-centric initiatives as primary drivers for these groups.
• Ken Gawrelski (Wells Fargo): Asked about Etsy’s competitive edge in on-site search compared to agentic platforms. Goyal emphasized that Etsy’s data and personalization strengths should deliver a more intent-driven experience than third-party agents.
• Shweta Khajuria (Wolfe Research): Inquired about the risk that AI agents could disrupt Etsy’s take rates or business model. Goyal acknowledged the uncertainty but underscored Etsy’s flexibility and proactive engagement with new platforms as mitigating factors.

What to Watch in the Coming Quarters

Looking ahead, the StockStory team will be tracking several key developments: (1) the speed and effectiveness of AI-driven personalization in boosting buyer engagement, (2) the impact of expanded marketing efforts—especially through social media and influencer collaborations—on attracting younger and returning customers, and (3) the execution of reinvestment strategies following the Depop divestiture. We’ll also monitor trends in purchase frequency and signs of renewed growth in Etsy’s core marketplace.

Currently, Etsy shares are trading at $53.44, up from $44.05 before the earnings release. Is there potential value in the stock?

Our Top Stock Picks Right Now

Relying on just a handful of stocks can make your portfolio vulnerable. Now is the time to secure high-quality investments before the market broadens and current prices disappear.

Don’t wait for the next market shock. Explore our Top 6 Stocks for This Week—a curated selection of high-quality companies that have delivered a 244% return over the past five years (as of June 30, 2025).

This list features well-known names like Nvidia, which soared 1,326% from June 2020 to June 2025, as well as lesser-known success stories such as Tecnoglass, which achieved a 1,754% five-year return. Discover your next standout investment with StockStory today.